Anonymous

50% off is its real value.

1 year ago Up 15 | Reply

Anonymous

I don't see the prices for 16GB/512GB M3 15-inch

1 year ago Up 2 | Reply

Anonymous

50% off is its real value.

1 year ago Up 15 | Reply

Anonymous

best deal since m3 macbook air announced

12 months ago Up 2 | Reply

Anonymous

15" at $1049 was a better deal in Nov/Dec

4 months ago Up 0 | Reply

Anonymous

I'd pull the trigger at $999.

3 months ago Up 0 | Reply

Anonymous

Soon. Coz M4 will be released today, //@anonymous: I'd pull the trigger at $999.

3 months ago Up 0 | Reply

Anonymous

I'd pay $1.

3 months ago Up 0 | Reply

Anonymous

Who cares //@anonymous: I'd pay $1.

2 months ago Up 0 | Reply

Anonymous

8GB and 256GB!!! That is a lot of RAM and storage.

1 year ago Up 3 | Reply

Anonymous

It’s the year of 2542 now. 8 gb and 256 gb. Come on apple. //@anonymous: 8GB and 256GB!!! That is a lot of RAM and storage.

1 year ago Up 6 | Reply

Anonymous

Oh wooh! 2542, someone from some 500 years future. //@Anonymous: It’s the year of 2542 now. 8 gb and 256 gb. Come on apple. //@anonymous: 8GB and 256GB!!! That is a lot of RAM and storage.

1 year ago Up 3 | Reply

Anonymous

If Apple puts 16G RAM / 512GB SSD for the entry model, more people would just buy the basic config without paying extra for the upgrade.

1 year ago Up 5 | Reply

Anonymous

When it comes, APPL still puts 8GB on MacBooks //@anonymous: Oh wooh! 2542, someone from some 500 years future. //@Anonymous: It’s the year of 2542 now. 8 gb and 256 gb. Come on apple. //@anonymous: 8GB and 256GB!!! That is a lot of RAM and storage.

1 year ago Up 2 | Reply

Anonymous

You can't change RAM but you can upgrade flash chip to 2T or 4T. Find someone help you to solder a new flash chip for upgrade.

1 year ago Up 3 | Reply

Anonymous

Somebody can do this can also upgrade RAM modules for you //@anonymous: You can't change RAM but you can upgrade flash chip to 2T or 4T. Find someone help you to solder a new flash chip for upgrade.

1 year ago Up 1 | Reply

Anonymous

You have to open the chip packaging //@anonymous: Somebody can do this can also upgrade RAM modules for you //@anonymous: You can't change RAM but you can upgrade flash chip to 2T or 4T. Find someone help you to solder a new flash chip for upgrade.

1 year ago Up 2 | Reply

Anonymous

Costco - another 2% off if you have Executive membership + 2 years warranty instead of 1. No brainer choice.

1 year ago Up 1 | Reply

Anonymous

Yep. For 1999. //@Anonymous: 8GB and 256GB!!! That is a lot of RAM and storage.

11 months ago Up 1 | Reply

Anonymous

Still only midnight and silver are for $849, and there is no clip coupon for the other two colors.

10 months ago Up 1 | Reply

Anonymous

all colors are $849 after $50 clip coupon now... //@Anonymous: Still only midnight and silver are for $849, and there is no clip coupon for the other two colors.

10 months ago Up 1 | Reply

Anonymous

At Costco it's $849.99 with 2-year-warranty

9 months ago Up 7 | Reply

Anonymous

I still remember at 1999, when i played red alert,it only required 16mb to run. //@anonymous: Yep. For 1999. //@Anonymous: 8GB and 256GB!!! That is a lot of RAM and storage.

7 months ago Up 2 | Reply

Anonymous

I'm still playing red alert as of today with rtx4060 32gb ram //@anonymous: I still remember at 1999, when i played red alert,it only required 16mb to run. //@anonymous: Yep. For 1999. //@Anonymous: 8GB and 256GB!!! That is a lot of RAM and storage.

4 months ago Up 0 | Reply

Anonymous

8G RAM kill the deal, Any deal with 16G RAM at least?

2 years ago Up 18 | Reply

Anonymous

So expensive

2 years ago Up 5 | Reply

learnserve

I would buy if it is $1199 or below

2 years ago Up 4 | Reply

Anonymous

Pass too crazy expensive

2 years ago Up 5 | Reply

Anonymous

Apple no longer sells to the low income market. Not surprising to hear people complain that they can't afford it. But if you can afford it, it's an incredible value.

2 years ago Up 6 | Reply

Anonymous

Ram is so cheap these days but still Apple sells a premium price laptop with only 8GB. And that is suppose to be a deal.

2 years ago Up 9 | Reply

Anonymous

8GB kills the deal.

2 years ago Up 4 | Reply

Anonymous

I bought at 1217 - Open box excellent at best buy. So good. It is just the same as new. //@learnserve: I would buy if it is $1199 or below

2 years ago Up 2 | Reply

Anonymous

They want the chip to overheat and fry so they can sell more mb’s in 3-4 years //@anonymous: Ram is so cheap these days but still Apple sells a premium price laptop with only 8GB. And that is suppose to be a deal.

2 years ago Up 4 | Reply

Anonymous

True, you basically have to spend 1600+ or else you are buying subpar equipment that will fail in 3 years //@anonymous: Apple no longer sells to the low income market. Not surprising to hear people complain that they can't afford it. But if you can afford it, it's an incredible value.

2 years ago Up 5 | Reply

Anonymous

Very much agree! //@Anonymous: 8GB kills the deal.

2 years ago Up 4 | Reply

Anonymous

Apple doesn’t do that. That sounds like a Lenovo strategy //@anonymous: They want the chip to overheat and fry so they can sell more mb’s in 3-4 years //@anonymous: Ram is so cheap these days but still Apple sells a premium price laptop with only 8GB. And that is suppose to be a deal.

2 years ago Up 8 | Reply

Anonymous

Now, as you know, apple chips are not getting much better, partly because of lack of good engineers and the slow improvement over the 3/4nm node. So... getting M1 pro instead may be a better idea.

2 years ago Up 4 | Reply

Anonymous

Previous gen M1 processors are a better value and should be more than sufficient for 70-80% of all users. If anything, Apple has bad marketing. No professional user is going to buy the MB with low specs, and no average user is going to spend $1.2K+ on it either. They should have significantly lowered the price, or not have an option with 8GB RAM/256GB storage.

2 years ago Up 7 | Reply

Anonymous

Don't pay Apple Tax

2 years ago Up 5 | Reply

Anonymous

This will not sell

2 years ago Up 4 | Reply

Anonymous

Lol at 8GB ram.

2 years ago Up 6 | Reply

Anonymous

It is simply too expensive compared to PC

2 years ago Up 5 | Reply

Anonymous

Agree! //@Anonymous: It is simply too expensive compared to PC

2 years ago Up 6 | Reply

Anonymous

1), M1 is super fast with no heat. 2), Mac is very efficient in using memory. I am a programmer converted from PC to MAC ~ 10 years ago, never look back. Of course, I bought a MacBook Pro, but I got a M1 MacBook Air for my son, he is very happy about it.

2 years ago Up 3 | Reply

Anonymous

With M processors RAM is IN the M2 processor. Completely different story compared to other laptops.
//@anonymous: Lol at 8GB ram.

2 years ago Up 3 | Reply

Anonymous

Ram is ram, built-in make it faster but that doesn’t make it larger //@anonymous: With M processors RAM is IN the M2 processor. Completely different story compared to other laptops.
//@anonymous: Lol at 8GB ram.

2 years ago Up 3 | Reply

Anonymous

Ram doesn’t make the computers run faster. It makes you open more programs at once. The cpu clock makes the computer runs faster. ( i7 12700 has 5ghz clock, it makes the computer run faster than i5 cpu) You need to understand the basic functions first. //@anonymous: Ram is ram, built-in make it faster but that doesn’t make it larger //@anonymous: With M processors RAM is IN the M2 processor. Completely different story compared to other laptops.
//@anonymous: Lol at 8GB ram.

2 years ago Up 3 | Reply

Anonymous

Agreed. Many people are talking nonsense //@Anonymous: Ram doesn’t make the computers run faster. It makes you open more programs at once. The cpu clock makes the computer runs faster. ( i7 12700 has 5ghz clock, it makes the computer run faster than i5 cpu) You need to understand the basic functions first. //@anonymous: Ram is ram, built-in make it faster but that doesn’t make it larger //@anonymous: With M processors RAM is IN the M2 processor. Completely different story compared to other laptops.
//@anonymous: Lol at 8GB ram.

2 years ago Up 2 | Reply

Anonymous

Not entirely true. When you run out of ram, which is relatively easy to do with only 8gb,the computer is forced to use swap space which is basically your ssd drive. Swapping memory pages in and out of disk is slow. I'd much rather have a slightly slower cpu with more memory. //@anonymous: Ram doesn’t make the computers run faster. It makes you open more programs at once. The cpu clock makes the computer runs faster. ( i7 12700 has 5ghz clock, it makes the computer run faster than i5 cpu) You need to understand the basic functions first.

2 years ago Up 3 | Reply

Anonymous

Your computer RAM is essentially short term memory where data is stored as the processor needs it. This isn't to be confused with long-term data that's stored on your hard drive, which stays there even when your computer is turned off.(info wouldn’t stay the your ram, the temporally memory pages are always on your SSD.) //@anonymous: Not entirely true. When you run out of ram, which is relatively easy to do with only 8gb,the computer is forced to use swap space which is basically your ssd drive. Swapping memory pages in and out of disk is slow. I'd much rather have a slightly slower cpu with more memory. //@anonymous: Ram doesn’t make the computers run faster. It makes you open more programs at once. The cpu clock makes the computer runs faster. ( i7 12700 has 5ghz clock, it makes the computer run faster than i5 cpu) You need to understand the basic functions first.

2 years ago Up 5 | Reply

Anonymous

costco link shows price $1,549

5 months ago Up 0 | Reply

Anonymous

M4 pro is significantly superior to M4, invest a bit more and go for M4 pro.

4 months ago Up 4 | Reply

Anonymous

Wrong information. They are same. Show your source //@anonymous: M4 pro is significantly superior to M4, invest a bit more and go for M4 pro.

3 weeks ago Up 0 | Reply

Anonymous

M4 Pro has more CPU and GPU cores, than M4. //@Anonymous: Wrong information. They are same. Show your source //@anonymous: M4 pro is significantly superior to M4, invest a bit more and go for M4 pro.

3 weeks ago Up 0 | Reply

Anonymous

With this all Apple deals. New iPad, iPad mini and watch is coming soon...

5 years ago Up 233 | Reply

Anonymous

Will there be new iPad Pro of 12 inch screen this year？

4 years ago Up 199 | Reply

Anonymous

Likely no more refreshes for the iPad pros this year... probably need to wait till at least Q1 of next year, maybe even September. //@anonymous: Will there be new iPad Pro of 12 inch screen this year？

4 years ago Up 199 | Reply

Anonymous

This is a really nice sale. Thank you, Dealsea!

5 years ago Up 1 | Reply

Anonymous

What website is this offer? //@anonymous: This is a really nice sale. Thank you, Dealsea!

5 years ago Up 1 | Reply

Anonymous

wow great deal! thank you very much!

5 years ago Up 2 | Reply

Anonymous

With this all Apple deals. New iPad, iPad mini and watch is coming soon...

5 years ago Up 233 | Reply

Anonymous

What are you trying to say? We all know that, and you get what you pay for... //@Anonymous: With this all Apple deals. New iPad, iPad mini and watch is coming soon...

4 years ago Up 1 | Reply

Anonymous

I do not see the $299 price at costco

4 years ago Up 0 | Reply

Anonymous

Only silver at walmart is 299

4 years ago Up 0 | Reply

Anonymous

So nice. $30 discount on a year old model. Bravo Amazon //@anonymous: Only silver at walmart is 299

4 years ago Up 1 | Reply

Anonymous

Thanks I got one gold

4 years ago Up 1 | Reply

Anonymous

Will there be new iPad Pro of 12 inch screen this year？

4 years ago Up 199 | Reply

Anonymous

Likely no more refreshes for the iPad pros this year... probably need to wait till at least Q1 of next year, maybe even September. //@anonymous: Will there be new iPad Pro of 12 inch screen this year？

4 years ago Up 199 | Reply

Anonymous

It only means that Apple Watches are not selling. //@Anonymous: With this all Apple deals. New iPad, iPad mini and watch is coming soon...

4 years ago Up 199 | Reply

Anonymous

Next Gen iPad pros is scheduled to release on April //@anonymous: Likely no more refreshes for the iPad pros this year... probably need to wait till at least Q1 of next year, maybe even September. //@anonymous: Will there be new iPad Pro of 12 inch screen this year？

4 years ago Up 0 | Reply

Anonymous

For all day wearing - congratulations you only need to work less than 5 hours everyday //@anonymous: Just pulled the trigger. Decent ANC, very comfortable for all day wearing. I am working at a lab with some servers.

2 months ago Up 97 | Reply

Anonymous

Got one, thanks!

6 months ago Up 56 | Reply

Anonymous

are they better than bose? or jvc?

5 months ago Up 32 | Reply

Anonymous

Any open box deals yet?

8 months ago Up 4 | Reply

Anonymous

Yep!! //@Anonymous: Any open box deals yet?

8 months ago Up 3 | Reply

oldwife

Why buy this when you can get the AirPods Pro 2 for $189?

8 months ago Up 7 | Reply

Anonymous

Gen 4 is more comfortable than pro //@oldwife: Why buy this when you can get the AirPods Pro 2 for $189?

8 months ago Up 6 | Reply

Anonymous

Comfort is in the ear of the beholder. //@Anonymous: Gen 4 is more comfortable than pro //@oldwife: Why buy this when you can get the AirPods Pro 2 for $189?

7 months ago Up 6 | Reply

Anonymous

rather wait for PS6

6 months ago Up 2 | Reply

Anonymous

Apple customers tend to have a more aristocratic sense of comfort. //@anonymous: Comfort is in the ear of the beholder. //@Anonymous: Gen 4 is more comfortable than pro //@oldwife: Why buy this when you can get the AirPods Pro 2 for $189?

6 months ago Up 9 | Reply

Anonymous

Gen 2 is more comfortable than Gen 4 //@anonymous: Gen 4 is more comfortable than pro //@oldwife: Why buy this when you can get the AirPods Pro 2 for $189?

6 months ago Up 5 | Reply

Anonymous

Got one, thanks!

6 months ago Up 56 | Reply

Anonymous

I noticed they tend to be better educated too //@Anonymous: Apple customers tend to have a more aristocratic sense of comfort. //@anonymous: Comfort is in the ear of the beholder. //@Anonymous: Gen 4 is more comfortable than pro //@oldwife: Why buy this when you can get the AirPods Pro 2 for $189?

6 months ago Up 5 | Reply

Anonymous

are they better than bose? or jvc?

5 months ago Up 32 | Reply

Anonymous

Apple fans do not ask such a question //@anonymous: are they better than bose? or jvc?

5 months ago Up 7 | Reply

Anonymous

True. Apple Fans are better than that. //@Anonymous: Apple fans do not ask such a question //@anonymous: are they better than bose? or jvc?

5 months ago Up 5 | Reply

Anonymous

Bestbuy can match price. just go chat with CS online

5 months ago Up 3 | Reply

Anonymous

148.99 at amazon lol

3 months ago Up 2 | Reply

Anonymous

It's actually opposite //@anonymous: True. Apple Fans are better than that. //@Anonymous: Apple fans do not ask such a question //@anonymous: are they better than bose? or jvc?

3 months ago Up 2 | Reply

Anonymous

Just pulled the trigger. Decent ANC, very comfortable for all day wearing. I am working at a lab with some servers.

3 months ago Up 4 | Reply

Anonymous

For all day wearing - congratulations you only need to work less than 5 hours everyday //@anonymous: Just pulled the trigger. Decent ANC, very comfortable for all day wearing. I am working at a lab with some servers.

2 months ago Up 97 | Reply

Anonymous

my phone costs lower than that

2 months ago Up 30 | Reply

Anonymous

Airpods pro keeps falling off from my ears. This 4 version fits much better.

1 week ago Up 0 | Reply

Anonymous

$1000 is a critical psychological line. Apple shouldn’t set the base model above it.

2 years ago Up 25 | Reply

Anonymous

More than $1000, still no touch screen, Apple is a joke.

2 years ago Up 13 | Reply

Anonymous

Everyone likes midnight

2 years ago Up 5 | Reply

Anonymous

fingerprint magnet //@Anonymous: Everyone likes midnight

2 years ago Up 2 | Reply

Anonymous

memory seems to be too small

2 years ago Up 5 | Reply

Anonymous

Go for higher memory then //@Anonymous: memory seems to be too small

2 years ago Up 3 | Reply

Anonymous

8gb is good enough. Windows pc needs 16gb. More than 16gb memory, the pc runs slowly than 16gb. //@anonymous: memory seems to be too small

2 years ago Up 4 | Reply

Anonymous

If all you do is browser based apps, word processing, YouTube, Facebook and social media consumption. Then this is more than enough. If you make 4K videos and are a YouTuber, then it wont be. Can do it…but will take a while.

2 years ago Up 5 | Reply

Anonymous

$1000 is a critical psychological line. Apple shouldn’t set the base model above it.

2 years ago Up 25 | Reply

Anonymous

13.6 inch

2 years ago Up 1 | Reply

cheetah

Thanks, updated. //@anonymous: 13.6 inch

2 years ago Up 1 | Reply

Anonymous

we are in recession. Wait for couple more months, the price will drop another 10% or more!!

2 years ago Up 4 | Reply

Anonymous

More than $1000, still no touch screen, Apple is a joke.

2 years ago Up 13 | Reply

learnserve

At BH, currently $1049

2 years ago Up 2 | Reply

Anonymous

also in inflation, so everything cost more? //@Anonymous: we are in recession. Wait for couple more months, the price will drop another 10% or more!!

2 years ago Up 2 | Reply

Anonymous

Either get MBA M1 or MBP 16GB

2 years ago Up 2 | Reply

Anonymous

Makes no sense, those are literally two different platforms. What exactly you are doing would change which one is better //@anonymous: Either get MBA M1 or MBP 16GB

2 years ago Up 0 | Reply

Anonymous

finally

2 years ago Up 0 | Reply

Anonymous

Be aware. The MBA M2 baseline 256GB model has a slower SSD.

2 years ago Up 2 | Reply

Anonymous

Can you replace the ssd? //@anonymous: Be aware. The MBA M2 baseline 256GB model has a slower SSD.

2 years ago Up 0 | Reply

Anonymous

No worry. Apple will set a new line for you. //@Anonymous: $1000 is a critical psychological line. Apple shouldn’t set the base model above it.

2 years ago Up 3 | Reply

Anonymous

Don’t need to. It’s not that slow. //@anonymous: Can you replace the ssd? //@anonymous: Be aware. The MBA M2 baseline 256GB model has a slower SSD.

2 years ago Up 1 | Reply

Anonymous

A lot of discounts on Apple products recently. M2 is their newest CPU and those laptops already on sale. Tough revenue quarter I suppose. Time of huge profits seems to be gone.

2 years ago Up 2 | Reply

Anonymous

Comment was correct //@anonymous: we are in recession. Wait for couple more months, the price will drop another 10% or more!!

2 years ago Up 1 | Reply

Anonymous

M2 Macbook air with 256GB SSD is a disaster. Better avoid it or get 512GB version.

2 years ago Up 3 | Reply

Anonymous

They just priced it wrong //@anonymous: A lot of discounts on Apple products recently. M2 is their newest CPU and those laptops already on sale. Tough revenue quarter I suppose. Time of huge profits seems to be gone.

2 years ago Up 4 | Reply

Anonymous

bummer... midnight is oos

2 years ago Up 0 | Reply

Anonymous

can we just have 16GB ram and 512GB disk for all entry level mac please

7 months ago Up 7 | Reply

Anonymous

Can I expect the price below $700 on black Friday?

6 months ago Up 1 | Reply

Anonymous

More than 4 years old model

6 months ago Up 1 | Reply

Anonymous

I am confused. The description says "2022." How could this be as old as you suggest? //@anonymous: More than 4 years old model

6 months ago Up 2 | Reply

Anonymous

My bad. It is 2 year old. //@anonymous: I am confused. The description says "2022." How could this be as old as you suggest? //@anonymous: More than 4 years old model

6 months ago Up 1 | Reply

Anonymous

you don’t buy, I don’t buy, price will lower twice

6 months ago Up 5 | Reply

Anonymous

Maybe after several years or never will happen, this is commercial strategy //@anonymous: Can I expect the price below $700 on black Friday?

6 months ago Up 1 | Reply

Anonymous

Costco increased price to 799

6 months ago Up 1 | Reply

Anonymous

@anonymousryou can contact Best Buy price match to 699.99. just tell them Brandsmart sell it with price 699.99 //@anonymous: Can I expect the price below $700 on black Friday?

3 months ago Up 1 | Reply

Anonymous

Best Buy now 699

2 months ago Up 1 | Reply

Anonymous

Waiting for $499

2 months ago Up 2 | Reply

Anonymous

2022 was a great year for MacBooks. Oh who am I kidding? Every year is a great year for MacBooks!

2 months ago Up 0 | Reply

Anonymous

where is the 549?

2 months ago Up 0 | Reply

Anonymous

I think you’re looking for 3 - 3 years old //@anonymous: My bad. It is 2 year old. //@anonymous: I am confused. The description says "2022." How could this be as old as you suggest? //@anonymous: More than 4 years old model

2 months ago Up 0 | Reply

Anonymous

But be careful, Amazon sellers also sell the fake variant.

2 years ago Up 26 | Reply

Anonymous

Yes, these buds are far, far better than any others and this price is good. There is a reason why you see so many people using AirPods and nobody uses other brands. //@Anonymous: is this a good deal?

2 years ago Up 19 | Reply

Anonymous

is this a good deal?

2 years ago Up 6 | Reply

Anonymous

Yes, these buds are far, far better than any others and this price is good. There is a reason why you see so many people using AirPods and nobody uses other brands. //@Anonymous: is this a good deal?

2 years ago Up 19 | Reply

Anonymous

Same chip as Gen 2.

2 years ago Up 3 | Reply

Anonymous

Costco has the same price.

2 years ago Up 3 | Reply

Anonymous

149.99 at Costco //@Anonymous: Costco has the same price.

2 years ago Up 2 | Reply

Anonymous

Most amazing!

2 years ago Up 8 | Reply

Anonymous

Boy howdy, it is a great deal! //@anonymous: is this a good deal?

2 years ago Up 9 | Reply

Anonymous

I lost track, is 3rd generation the latest/current ?

2 years ago Up 3 | Reply

Anonymous

Yes - Gen 3 is the latest for the regular Airpods. For 'Pro" version, the latest is Gen 2 //@Anonymous: I lost track, is 3rd generation the latest/current ?

2 years ago Up 6 | Reply

Anonymous

But be careful, Amazon sellers also sell the fake variant.

2 years ago Up 26 | Reply

Anonymous

Bought a pair thanks

2 years ago Up 5 | Reply

Anonymous

They are the best

2 years ago Up 7 | Reply

Anonymous

HOT deal!!

2 years ago Up 4 | Reply

Anonymous

super hot. gen 3! //@anonymous: HOT deal!!

2 years ago Up 3 | Reply

Anonymous

4Th generation is coming

2 years ago Up 2 | Reply

Anonymous

YES!! When?!? I’m getting this 3rd Gen. now but I’ll be ready to get Gen. 4 as soon as it comes out! :D //@anonymous: 4Th generation is coming

2 years ago Up 6 | Reply

Anonymous

It’s not hot deal, it’s good deal if you are planning to buy now, only $20 off.

2 years ago Up 7 | Reply

Anonymous

These work great for music, gaming or even phone calls, unlike competing products. There is literally nothing Apple cannot do better than other companies.

2 years ago Up 5 | Reply

Anonymous

WOW! AWESOME!!

2 years ago Up 6 | Reply

Anonymous

How about siri? Also there is nothing Apple can’t charge less than other companies. //@anonymous: These work great for music, gaming or even phone calls, unlike competing products. There is literally nothing Apple cannot do better than other companies.

2 years ago Up 1 | Reply

Anonymous

169.99 at costco

2 years ago Up 2 | Reply

Anonymous

It is also good because many people (including me) don't like the plug in the Pro version.

1 year ago Up 2 | Reply

Anonymous

No noise cancellation at this price range? //@Anonymous: Yes, these buds are far, far better than any others and this price is good. There is a reason why you see so many people using AirPods and nobody uses other brands. //@Anonymous: is this a good deal?

1 year ago Up 0 | Reply

Anonymous

Till end of month, Costco has them for $139 in the store

1 year ago Up 0 | Reply

Anonymous

Costco: Apple AirPods (3rd Generation) with MagSafe Charging Case for $139.99 #skc

1 year ago Up 2 | Reply